Episode Transcript

Active Voice Versus Passive Voice
Episode 46: March 25, 2007

Grammar Girl here.

Today's topic is active voice versus passive voice.

Here's Brian from Iowa:

“It drives me crazy when people write in passive voice. How can I teach people how to tell the difference between passive and active voice and stay away from passive voice? Thanks.”


A lot of you have asked me to explain passive voice and how to avoid it.

I'll start with active voice because it's simpler. In an active sentence, the subject is doing the action. A very straightforward example is the sentence "Steve loves Amy." Steve is the subject, and he is doing the action: he loves Amy, the object. Another example is the title of the Marvin Gaye song I Heard It through the Grapevine. I is the subject, the one who is doing the action. I is hearing it, the object of the sentence.

In passive voice the target of the action gets promoted to the subject position. Instead of saying, "Steve loves Amy," I would say, "Amy is loved by Steve." The subject of the sentence becomes Amy, but she isn't doing anything. Rather, she is just the recipient of Steve's love. The focus of the sentence has changed from Steve to Amy. If you wanted to make the title of the Marvin Gaye song passive, you would say It Was Heard by Me through the Grapevine, not such a catchy title anymore.

A lot of people think that all sentences that contain a form of the verb to be are in passive voice, but that isn't true. For example, the sentence "I am holding a pen" is in active voice, but it uses the verb am, which is a form of to be. The passive form of that sentence is "The pen is being held by me."

Another important point is that passive sentences aren't incorrect; it’s just that they often aren't the best way to phrase your thoughts. Sometimes passive voice is awkward and other times it’s vague.

When you put sentences in passive voice, it's easy to leave out the agent doing the action. For example, "Amy is loved" is passive. The problem with that sentence is that you don't know who loves Amy. In fact, politicians often use passive voice to intentionally obscure the idea of who is taking the action. Ronald Reagan famously said, “Mistakes were made” when referring to the Iran-Contra scandal. Other examples of passive voice for political reasons could include “Bombs were dropped” and “Shots were fired.” Since I started writing this episode, I've become more aware of passive voice, and it seems as if I hear politicians use it every day.

So, these are some of the reasons to avoid passive voice: the form can lead to awkward sentences and obscured meaning. Also, passive voice is wordy. You can tighten up your writing a lot if you use active voice more often than passive.

On the other hand, Mike from Chicago correctly pointed out that there are instances where passive voice is the best choice. If you don't know who is taking the action, then you can't name that person. Depending on the context, it might make more sense to write, “The cookies were stolen,” instead of, “Somebody stole the cookies.” It's a subtle difference. If you want to put the focus on the cookies, use passive voice. Alternatively, if you want to put the focus on the unknown thief, use active voice. If you were writing a mystery novel you might want to highlight the cookies if their specific disappearance were central to the story. So you would choose passive voice and say, “The cookies were stolen.” So passive voice is often a good choice when the actor isn't known or doesn't matter, or if you want to create some mystery around your sentence.

So remember, in a passive-voice sentence the subject of the sentence is the receiver of the action. Passive voice is not grammatically incorrect; it's just not often the best choice. If you know who did what, it’s better to use an active sentence in most cases.

That's all.

I apologize for posting the show late this week,but I have a really good excuse. I was putting the final touches on my new audiobook: Grammar Girl's Quick and Dirty Tips to Clean Up Your Writing. I'm so excited to have it out. It's a one-hour downloadable audiobook covering 24 different topics. The content is mostly from the podcast archives, but there is some new stuff mixed in, the shows are grouped by topic, it's higher quality audio than you get from the podcasts, and it's just grammar (so there aren't any listener questions or announcements like you get in the podcasts).

You can buy the book right now at audible.com, and it will be available in a day or two in the audiobooks section at iTunes. If you've ever wanted to support the show, this is a great way to do it. I think it's a great deal too: It's only $4.95 and you get something really useful. Also, I want the people at my publishing company to be happy that they took a chance on a podcaster. So please, buy the book.

As always, this is Grammar Girl. You'll find a transcript of this podcast at QuickAndDirtyTips.com Remember, if you want to call in with a question, the number is 206-338-GIRL. Send e-mails to feedback@quickanddirtytips.com.

Web Bonus: Advanced Material

One way to tell your sentence is passive is if the subject isn't taking a direct action. In addition, a passive-voice sentence will always contain a past participle, it will usually contain a form of the verb to be, and it will sometimes contain the word by. These three sentences contain one or more passive-voice components: Shot in the leg, he hobbled to the hospital. He was shot in the leg. The purse-snatcher was shot in the leg by the angry grandma.

Thank you to Steve Thornton and Bonnie Trenga


Comments (74) for Active Voice Versus Passive Voice |  Subscribe to Comment

jony Says:
7/2/2009 2:00:47 PM
what is the passive form of "i go to school"
Emal Nahib Zada Says:
6/4/2009 12:26:26 AM
Hi i have Problume with active and passive voice, can some send me the rule of it, means how we can change active to passive voice you can mail me, e_nahibzada@yahoo.com or emalnahibzada@gmail.com
Arvin Says:
5/30/2009 12:48:14 AM
Why use active & passive voice
TAREK Says:
5/27/2009 3:55:31 AM
Please tell me when you cannot use the passive voice
robyn Says:
4/12/2009 3:38:05 AM
this article has been approved by me. (I approve of this article)
Marcus Says:
4/8/2009 8:33:31 PM
I think you forgot to mention that a passive sentence can only be formed when a sentence has a transative verb (a verb that takes an object). "I drove a car" can be changed to passive because the verb "drove" has an object, "car". The passive would read, "A car was driven by me." But "I drove to school" doesn't have an object, the verb is intransative in this case and the sentence can't be make passive. Instances when the passive is preferred over the active: 1)When the agent doing the action is unknown. 2)When the agent doing the action is not important. 3)When the agent doing the action is non-human. 4) When the agent doing the action is new information.
Matt Says:
3/11/2009 12:21:02 PM
It's always important to focus on the cookies :P
Katty..! *.* Says:
2/25/2009 8:20:01 PM
Woow..! I have to say it was an excellent explanation..Thank you so much for being so clear with this subject.. It helps me so much with my english course..I'm improving my english and it has been an important information..! I didnt have it so clearly in my mind..xD
Natalia Says:
12/31/2008 5:01:11 AM
I was wondering about whether you should use the passive voice in resumes and personal statements? I was reading a friend's personal statement which she had written for an application into Graduate School and it was littered with the passive voice. I thought it lacked clarity and power but she did not seem to agree. She is an Urban Development student and I wondered if her educational background may be the reason for our different styles? Any thoughts?
roy jet Says:
12/14/2008 8:33:31 AM
cool!
peace Says:
10/21/2008 3:19:47 AM
why used passive voice?
jamaritoshaka Says:
10/16/2008 8:27:10 PM
hello oh its nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!hahahahah
Daniel Jaime Says:
9/6/2008 11:43:26 AM
Thanks a lot for this lesson.
nuxu Says:
9/3/2008 2:30:39 PM
i've been browsing the net to find exercises i can conduct in my classroom in passive voice and so far i've had no luck. do u include exercises on grammar lessons
George Says:
8/12/2008 6:13:06 AM
"She will be loved" is passive, yes? Which happens to be the title of a very popular Maroon 5 song. So passive voice isn't always a bad thing... In fact, the title of that song wouldn't work with active voice, "Someone will love her" isn't as poetic...
p.vijay Says:
8/7/2008 7:20:25 AM
greetings sir/madam i have one doubt thatmy friend gave asentence."sheeta sings on the stage" right now i can not transforminto passive voice.because there is no object.so,please! help me to chenge into passive with an explanartion
dafe Says:
7/30/2008 12:26:44 PM
very nice
Mohammad Danish Says:
7/30/2008 5:18:39 AM
It is so easy to give impression while writing so paragraph on any subject, but it is so difficult to know the sentences between the active voice and passive voice. Could you teach us how instant we can discriminate between these components. Please advise easiest way. Thanks & Best regards
cheerio_888 Says:
7/29/2008 12:38:24 PM
Thanks a lot for this lesson.
k a rafe Says:
3/17/2008 1:33:35 AM
What will be the passive of : Enter by the door.
meri andayani Says:
2/6/2008 2:53:31 AM
excellent
MERARIS PEÑA Says:
1/25/2008 10:29:12 AM
The information was so importan and i learnd a lot of that knowlages.
kimesha gammon Says:
1/25/2008 7:51:51 AM
good
vasundhara Says:
1/19/2008 12:25:12 AM
English is a great language and very interesting. active and passive voice are my favriout topics. my english teacher gave an oppurtnity to teach voices in class
kate Says:
1/10/2008 12:14:31 AM
I love english subject but in first it is hard to understand because i can't speak english. many teachers thougt me so i undstand this subject.......
Bailey Says:
12/17/2007 5:07:42 PM
Ths really helped with my English Final. I am in the 8th grade and I am in Pre-Ap-English and I was just wondering how to use active and passive voices because it was going to be on my test. Also I made an A on the English portioon of my test and I can thank "Grammar Girl" for that.
shashikant Says:
12/14/2007 6:49:48 AM
Plz help me!!!!!!! What will be the passive of the following sentence: "She has a new book"
crystal Says:
12/4/2007 1:52:02 AM
The flowers were given to me. can you change it to active and with explaination?
Kim Says:
11/26/2007 2:39:16 PM
Hi... Can anyone tell me which sentence structure is correct? The message is displayed in the pop-up window. OR The message displays in the pop-up window. And also answer WHY which of the above is correct citing the grammar rule? Thanks!
Dean Says:
11/20/2007 8:32:22 AM
Christine Wilson: To answer your question about asking patients if they are (number)or (more numb). You only need to ask them if they are numb. Numb is absolute, you can not be more numb, the patient is either numb or they are not numb.
JEAN ECHIZEN Says:
11/15/2007 11:07:28 PM
i would like to know some passive examples. i need it right away so please send it to me right away to this e-mail:shane_cat39@yahoo.com.thank you.jean echizen
Usman Says:
10/5/2007 11:17:19 AM
These all are good and I learnt a lot about the Active and Passive Voice. but please explain us how to use the Empatic sentence. (May and Might). as well as explain preperly please.... i will be very thank full to you people.
Grammar Girl Says:
8/4/2007 5:42:53 PM
Some people use the comma (called a serial comma) and other people don't. It's a style issue. I covered serial commas in a recent episode: http://urltea.com/153b -----
leannkay Says:
8/3/2007 5:35:22 AM
I would like to know when it is okay to leave out the comma before the "and" in a list. I thought that it was correct to put the comma before the "and", but have see it both ways. -----
Bettina Says:
7/29/2007 8:41:58 PM
What determines when one uses the word 'eldest' instead of 'oldest' in a sentence? -----
Meline Says:
5/12/2007 5:00:51 PM
I think you are right about putting the focus on the process rather than the actor. I would add, active voice can sometimes establish a cause and effect relationship -- but scientists must not make those assumptions. They must observe the effects and chronicle them, without presumptions and preconceptions about cause. -----
Kristen and Mary Says:
5/8/2007 11:48:49 PM
We enjoyed your podcasts e.g., i.e. and e.g. :) We were wondering about how you run the business. What challenges did you overcome in the creation of Grammar Girl? What is your favorite part of the job? Were there any times when you thought that Grammar Girl was a bad idea or felt like giving up? How did you get the idea for Grammar Girl? What do you think made Grammar Girl so successful? Thanks for listening. -----
Sheriese Says:
5/8/2007 11:37:37 PM
Hello I just wanted to let you know that your Grammar Girl podcast is very helpful and can help everybody know their grammar better. Can you explain to me what the differences are between effect and affect? -----
Colleen Says:
5/8/2007 10:10:56 PM
Can you clarify oldest vs. eldest? Can you include a table of contents or a search on your site? -----
Marissa Says:
5/8/2007 6:14:27 PM
Can you possibly write about "auburn" versus "amber"? They reference the same color, but why do they have different usage? Why does one refer to hair color and the other just the color or stone? -----
Matt Sokoloff Says:
4/30/2007 2:56:49 AM
Good call...I'm pretty sure I've done that before and never thought about it. -----
Tom Says:
4/24/2007 6:48:55 AM
I think it's because articles need to be formal and impersonal. "The subjects were shown three images" sounds more formal and less personal than "I showed the subjects three images" and less stuffy than "The author showed the subjects three images". -----
Carlo Says:
4/20/2007 4:58:45 AM
In honor of passive sentences, did anyone catch AG Alberto Gonzales' testimony today? I lost count of how many times he said "Mistakes were made..." Take some ownership, kid! -----
Siberlee Says:
4/17/2007 10:03:48 AM
This was a great introduction to the subject! It is probably more than enough for what most people need. As you look for future subjects, may I suggest a “how to identify the passive voice in your own writing” and then of course “how to fix it”. I work with a lot of aspiring fantasy writers and I must say that writing passively is the biggest problem I see on a regular basis. I would write it myself, but alas, I am often an offender myself and my knowledge of what is technically correct or not correct is sorely lacking. I just know when something is written good (woops – well! - ~wink~), and when it is not - but don’t always know the reason why. In any case great article – if you ever do the “how to” one please let me know. -----
brainwise Says:
4/7/2007 5:37:01 AM
Hi there, Grammar Girl. I've been listening to your podcasts and I find them to be refreshing and informative. I have been a technical writer since 1991, but your podcasts give me a necessary refresher. Technical writers are notorious for the passive voice, particularly those of us who write for computer systems. But I do what I can. Speaking of doing what I can, when I heard about your book, I knew I had to support your work by purchasing a copy through iTunes. I'll be listening to it at the office next week. Keep up the great work. -----
Christena Wilson Says:
3/31/2007 3:21:23 AM
Thanks! I had to force myself to print that out and show my boss. I still refuse to say "Are you number?" It sounds awful, like a redneck...lol Thanks again! -----
jenn Says:
3/30/2007 3:15:33 AM
Moving from an academic (Chemistry) to a business environment after finishing my degree, one of the biggest differences was getting used to write in the active voice. But having practiced this for a while, I find that I like my writing a lot better in the active. But at school, we were told to ALWAYS write in the passive. It does make sense in some science/academic scenarios, but a lot of the time it is just unnecessary words... Thanks for clarifying a few things about it! -----
Penny Chapin Says:
3/29/2007 11:12:01 PM
Mignon, Your name is so uncommon, the only other person I have ever heard with that name is my cousin Gingers daughter. Her aunt is Joyce, Sonny and Lucille were grandparents. I moved and have not seen these girls for years. If this is you please get a hold of me at Penny Chapin - 503-375-6009. I am in Salem, Oregon Thank you, I would love to be in touch ! -----
Chelsea Says:
3/29/2007 8:47:46 PM
Whoa! Calm down Amy! -----
Chelsea Says:
3/29/2007 8:46:24 PM
I can't wait to buy the audiobook! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! -----
John Says:
3/29/2007 2:41:58 PM
http://www.bartleby.com/61/12/N0191200.html numb Inflected forms: numb·er, numb·est
Grammar Girl Says:
3/29/2007 4:37:04 AM
The audiobook is all that exists right now. I'm working on a print book, but it will be months before it is available. If you sign up for the newsletter using the button at www.qdnow.com, you will be notified when the book is available (and will get occasional notices about what is going on with the QDnow shows). -----
amy Says:
3/29/2007 2:39:49 AM
AM SERIOUSLY. WHERE CAN I BUY THIS FRICKING BOOK??? ALL I SEE ARE ADS FOR THE FRICKING AUDIO CRAP. I WANT THE BOOK-- WHERE DO I GET THE BOOK "GRAMMAR GIRL"?????????????? -----
Christena Wilson Says:
3/29/2007 2:01:05 AM
Hello! I seen you on Oprah and am dying to ask you a question. This will end a 5 year debate with my boss (Dentist). Here goes: After giving patient novicaine, he will ask them later if they are "numb(er)". I say that you ask if they are "more numb". I can't find the word number (from numb) in any dictionary. Please help!! I told him that I was going to email you and ask, you will have the final say! Thank you! -----
Kevin Andrew Murphy Says:
3/28/2007 9:40:41 PM
Sri, It's pretty easy: An immigrant is someone who moves to a place, an emigrant is someone who moves away. Of course, these can both can refer to the same person, so someone who has moved from Mexico to the United States has emigrated from Mexico but immigrated to the United States. From the perspective of someone in neither of the two countries, the person is a migrant who has migrated. -----
Sri Says:
3/28/2007 8:29:44 PM
Hi Grammar Girl, I have a question for you. Immigrated vs. Emigrated (or immigration versus emigration). I have seen both but am unsure what the difference is, and when to use emigrated in partcular! Thanks, Sri -----
Sheila Says:
3/28/2007 8:06:02 PM
I think that the most important point in your article is the fact that passive voice is not ALWAYS a bad choice. I recently wrote several training manuals for computer programmers. Because the books were intended for an international audience, the customer decided that active voice was easier to understand and I was not allowed to use passive voice. This was incredibly frustrating because most of the time the 'actor' did not matter at all and the sentences became very awkward when they were put in active voice. I recently heard about your podcast on NPR and I have been listening ever since. Keep up the great work! -----
Zana Says:
3/28/2007 1:11:00 PM
I think you are great. I saw you on Oprah Monday loved how your whipping people in to shape about their grammar. Do you plan to list your info on your website or write a book. I am not a fan of audio books and am sure there was a reason you created one. But I am old fashioned and like to read books and refer to them when needed. Again, thank you Grammar Girl. -----
Kevin Andrew Murphy Says:
3/28/2007 6:08:25 AM
I'm a fiction writer. Another reason to use passive voice in some instances is when the subject is more interesting and germane to the story than whatever it was that acted upon him, her or it. For example, the passive At the age of five, he was bitten by a werewolf keeps a better focus on the subject of the story than the active When he was five, a werewolf bit him. Similarly, there are shades of meaning between the passive and the active: She was intrigued by poisons keeps the focus on the passive "she" and makes us think that she may be contemplating murder, whereas the active Poisons intrigued her gives the force of the sentence to the poison and makes the reader think the woman may be instead contemplating suicide. -----
Alice Says:
3/28/2007 4:22:48 AM
Saw you on Oprah. I'm so glad you are out there. I have found myself not knowing things like, whom or who, and now I can know with your Web site. I also bought your audio book on iTunes. thanks! -----
denny mike Says:
3/28/2007 3:33:50 AM
Tried to buy your book, but the State field would not work, so I couldn't say I'm from California. Also, couldn't therefore recommend to friends that they buy your book since I couldn't at all. -denny mike -----
Crystal Says:
3/28/2007 2:15:54 AM
Hello, I would like to know if you can recommend a book for writing essay's.My son has to write a 500 word essay for school and he can use the help. thank you
Zach Everson Says:
3/28/2007 1:49:34 AM
Great tip--and kudos for mentioning how people use the passive voice to avoid responsibility. -----
Brika Says:
3/28/2007 12:57:59 AM
I love you so much. My friend, Alden Rogers, told me about you. -----
John Says:
3/27/2007 5:32:16 PM
"It drives me crazy when people write in passive voice." No, this sentence is neither passive or subjunctive. The passive voice needs better PR. http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003414.html -----
Vik Says:
3/27/2007 12:50:08 PM
Wow! I never thought about it that way. Thanks to you I won't ever make that mistake again. -----
Amy Says:
3/27/2007 2:16:00 AM
I saw you on Oprah the other day! I think you are so awesome! I love your website! -----
steve Says:
3/27/2007 1:42:45 AM
I cannot stand to hear people say they received numerous "e-mails". Mail is plural. Why do people insist on putting an "s" on e-mail. A person wouldn't say I received my mails in the mails box!!! This is gramatically incorrect!!! -----
jerry coughlin Says:
3/26/2007 10:48:46 PM
I was so proud of you on Oprah, you were wonderful. way to go! Love Jerry Coughlin -----
Jason Woertink Says:
3/26/2007 10:47:08 PM
To me it seems that passive voice is more acceptable in scientific publications. The first reason is that it is already clear that the authors of the paper were the ones that completed work. So sentences like "Joe Smith added benzene to the reaction." is redundant. Second, scientific procedures and experiments should work no matter who is doing them. So to say that "Joe Smith added the benzene." suggests that it is important that Joe Smith is to be the one to add the benzene and not some one else. Thus the sentence "Benzene was added to the reaction." is more common and seems fine. -----
Morgan Says:
3/26/2007 10:35:48 PM
Hi. I'm curious *why* the passive voice is preferred in 'engineer' English. It frustrates me when manuals/signs/etc hide away behind this kind of language. eg Passengers are asked to wait behind the line, etc. What's wrong with being the protagonist? -----
James Welborn Says:
3/26/2007 8:11:02 PM
Is this sentence in the passive voice? “It drives me crazy when people write in passive voice." I know that "it" is doing the driving here, but "it" isn't named until later. (Is the "when people ..." technically a subjunctive clause?) It could be rewritten as "The passive voice drives me crazy" or "When people write in the passive voice, it drives me crazy," which both seem more active, but not necessarily better. I may just be on crack today, though. -----
J. Cabello Says:
3/26/2007 7:22:44 PM
I am an engineer, and I find myself often battling the issue of the passive voice with MS Word's grammar check. When I first learned english I was taught that the passive voice is often not the best choice in english. However, when I later attended university, I learned that for technical writing it still is the preferred choice. Now that I work in industry I still find it a bit of a conundrum, for while it is clear to me that when writing a technical paper, I should never use the personal pronoun, and if I must refer to myself, I must be referred to as "the author", I think that it is important in electronic business communication to make it clear who the subject of the action is, for which the passive voice is not a good choice. Where I'm not always clear is when I write internal reports which are not due to be published, where I feel that using the active form would force me to use first pronouns, which I see as "untechnical" yet the passive voice leaves it unclear when I am stating my opinion or choice vs company policy or commonly accepted ground within my discipline. -----
IHateToast Says:
3/26/2007 10:41:25 AM
This would be going back a long time now, but I thought I remembered articles in science journals as being written in passive, while the humanities preferred the active. As I said. It was a long time ago. There were flocks of seagulls and 100 haircuts, so I might be wrong. -----

Add Comment

 *
 *
 *
  Image to deter spam submissions
  To deter spam submissions, please type the letters from the image into the box below:
 *
 
  Fields marked with "*" are required