Episode Transcript

Should Writers Keep a Journal?
Episode 187: September 11, 2009

Grammar Girl here.

Today we're going to talk about keeping a journal.

But first, we're sponsored by Audible. If you sign up for a free trial at audiblepodcast.com/gg, you also get a free audiobook to keep even if you cancel.

If you're an aspiring writer, you've probably heard that writers should keep a writing journal. The first time I kept a real writing journal was in my freshman English class in college, so since it's the beginning of the school year and some of you may be keeping a journal for the first time, it also seemed like a good time to cover the topic.

What Is a Writing Journal?

Keeping a journal is a very personal thing, so I'm going to give you guidelines and advice based on my experiences, but know that whatever works for you, is the right thing for you to do.

The idea of keeping a journal is that writers need to write, and you don't always have assignments or projects underway, or you have ideas that aren't fully formed and need to be worked out. Your journal is where you work out those ideas or write when you don't have anything formal to write about.

An Ideas Journal

You may keep a journal on hand to write down those flash ideas that come to you out of nowhere: a great topic for a blog post, a great title for a short story, or the perfect background detail for your main character. That's the kind of journal I keep these days.

A Daily Journal

Or you may set aside 15 minutes every day to write in your journal as a way to stay disciplined or get in the writing spirit before you start working on you “real” projects.

A Freewriting Journal

I know one author who loves to freewrite a bit before he starts working on his novel. Freewriting is when you sit down and force yourself to write whatever comes to mind without stopping for a set period of time. It often helps people brainstorm or overcome writer's block.

A Dream Journal

Some people have frequent dreams and keep a notepad by their bed to write down notes as soon as they wake up. Other people like to write before they go to bed every night to get things out on paper and clear their mind, whereas other people find that writing before going to bed can get them to start thinking about things and then make it hard to sleep.

A Diary or a Journal?

I'm not a big fan of keeping a journal about your daily life, your feelings, and your deepest darkest secrets. My mom told me to never put anything in writing that I didn't want others to read, and I ignored her advice and learned that lesson the hard way.

With that said, some people find this to be the most inspirational type of journaling, that the easiest thing to write about is their personal life, or it's a helpful way to work through feelings. A personal journal can also be the most rewarding type of writing to go back and reread 20 years later in that boy-was-I-a-goofball kind of way.

If you're going to keep a personal journal, and you want to really explore your feelings, take care to keep it secure. An anonymous blog on a site like Blogger or Wordpress can be a safer way to keep this kind of journal as long as you don't use identifying information because it isn't something that someone can find in your room or physically take from you. You'll never accidentally leave it on the bus.

I met one writer who keeps this kind of very personal journal, but keeps them in a locked cabinet and has specified in her will that they be destroyed without being read upon her death, and has designated a person to do it who has promised to carry out her wishes.

What Format Will Work for You?

So, let's say you've decided to keep a journal. Are you the kind of person who will be inspired by a fancy, leather-bound journal or intimidated by it? Make sure you pick something that will work for you. Don't make it feel too special. You can even do it on the computer, Doogie Howser style. Maybe the best thing for you is something small that you can carry around with you so you always have it handy when you have an idea.

I like to date my journal entries, but I can't think of a particularly good reason why you should unless you expect to defend the invention date in court.

Also, don't go back and edit your entries. This isn't about getting perfect writing. It's about practicing writing and exploring your ideas. It should be something that won't be judged, graded, or really read by others. It's most effective if it's a safe place.

Your journal is primarily for writing, but there's no rule that says you couldn't also paste in pictures or draw photos. I've pasted things into my journal that I wrote on other pieces of paper when I didn't have my journal handy.

Can You Spend too Much Time Journaling?

Here's one question I've pondered: Can you spend too much time journaling? I've met people who say they spend at least an hour a day writing in a journal. For most writers I know, at least those who have families and jobs, one of the biggest challenges they face is finding time to write, to work on their book, or short stories, or blog. So when I hear of people spending so much time journaling, I wonder if it has become a procrastination tool.

If you're spending an hour every day on your journal, ask yourself why you aren't working an hour every day on a writing project that will get in front of readers. There may be times early in a project when you need to spend a lot of time fleshing out ideas, but just because you don't have an assignment doesn't mean you can't be working on writing that could become a project or could be read by real live people.

No Pressure

Finally, don't feel like you're a failure as a writer if you don't keep a journal. I've actually met people who feel guilty that they don't keep a journal. It's a great tool for some people, but if it doesn't work for you, don't worry about it. Maybe try it again in a year or two, but don't think you're somehow obligated to keep a journal just because you're a writer.

Audible

This week I've been really sick and forced to rest, which I hate doing. About the only thing that kept me sane was listening to audiobooks, and I found one I think you're going to love. It's called The Adventure of English by Melvyn Bragg and it goes from the very beginning of English when the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes took over England to the present day and catalogs all the changes in between. It's incredibly entertaining if you love words and language, and it's over 12 hours long, so it's a great deal if you choose it as your free audiobook from Audible. Visit audiblepodcast.com/gg to get The Adventure of English as your free book when you sign up for a free two-week trial.

Dealista

And, Quick and Dirty Tips has another new podcast that I think you'll enjoy. It's called The Dealista's Quick and Dirty Tips for Getting More for Less Money. That sounds good, right? Everyone likes deals. She'll tell you how to take advantage of price matching, double coupons, and the discounting schedule at Target, among other things. Check her out at quickanddirtytips.com and subscribe at iTunes.

That's all. I'm Mignon Fogarty, author of the New York Times bestseller Grammar Girl's Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing, and I have new book coming out October 13 called The Grammar Devotional. Thanks for listening.


Comments (10) for Should Writers Keep a Journal?  |  Subscribe to Comment

donna Says:
10/23/2009 6:51:24 PM
an ideas journal works good for me
Ayesha Says:
9/30/2009 3:58:20 PM
I've been keeping pretty consistent journals since I was 8 years old (I'm 21 now). It's not so much of an account of the day as much as it's a place to think, observe, try new things, & work through life. It's really helpful for my writing to go back-- sometimes you can draw inspiration from a sentence you scribbled out. Just offering my opinion =).
Mark Says:
9/29/2009 12:04:20 PM
GG - I'm not sure my definition of a writing journal is the same as yours. I agree that a journal can be a place to "work out ideas, or write when you don't have anything formal to write about." However, you also include a journal as a place to keep "flash ideas" such as a "great topic for a blog post." Would this journal of yours also include a great idea for a gift for a friend or family member? How about the broccoli you need to buy for tonigh's dinner recipe? In my case, these types of things, along with blog ideas and virtually any other idea for that matter, are "list" items not "journal" entries. In other words, I'm not sure a journal is a great place for lists, especially if the purpose of the journal is to help you write better. Alternatively, I simply cannot live without all my lists. Perhaps managing lists is another possible topic for a GG episode?
orio Says:
9/29/2009 11:34:04 AM
If a writer is really afraid about the content of his journal being read by others, one option is to have a livejournal account. The group that handles livejournal is very good in terms of security and if the writer does not tell anyone about his account, it's difficult to track and hack. Posts can also be made private so only you can read them. I've been keeping journal notebooks since I was a freshman in high school and I found out that it helps as you grow as both a person and a writer. I haven't tried setting a specific time to write daily but it's a handy tool when you're sitting in the bus and an idea hits you. As grammar girl said, you can paste pictures or doodle in it and I find writing down unusual names of places or people, quotes or events helpful for future reference. Skimming the funnier stories also serve as a good pick-me-up on bad days. :)
tapeboy Says:
9/18/2009 5:17:05 AM
[Advice from someone that recently began keeping a journal.] Why: I am in my (very) early thirties and have recently realized I have forgotten a lot of stuff/details of past events. Close friends tell of stories that I cannot remember and vice-versa. The realization is that If I cannot remember details that occurred in my early 20s in my early 30s, how is that going to play out when I am 60!? When/What: Everyday. I keep my journal icon on my desktop and pull it up everyday to write in it. Many days may only be one or two sentences long. (Just the highlights.) But I cannot imagine how useful all of those days will be when I string them together in 30 years. Some days, I write more--major events... personal inflection, etc. Where/How: This was the hardest thing. I did not want to keep that "leather-bound journal" or anything else that someone could find. I also did not want to have a journal ONLINE at Blogger or Wordpress... something that could be hacked... or may hang around forever if something happened to me. My Solution: I installed Wordpress on my local machine--personal computer. It allows me to have password protection. I can back it up to Mozy or some other service. I can access it remotely if I want to... And unless I want it to live on, then it will die with me upon destruction of my hard drive and default of monthly payments to Mozy. Wordpress allows me to have journal entries arranged by date, topic, or whatever else I want automatically.... plus, pictures, videos, weblinks, etc... and it has a search feature built into it! It is very fast, very easy, very secure (since it is not on a public webserver). Just thought I would share what has become a PERFECT solution for me. If you are interested in setting up something like this for yourself, take a look at http://lifehacker.com/software/feature/how-to-set-up-a-personal-home-web-server-124212.php to set a home websever with Apache (it runs in the background). Or just go to the Apache website directly http://httpd.apache.org/download.cgi to get it. Of course, you will need to install Wordpress separately on your computer afterward.
Alex Luviano Says:
9/15/2009 5:47:46 PM
I think grammar girl had some good ideas about how to write in a journal. Also it was mostly telling us to write in your journal at least 5 minutes a day to improve our writing. It also doesnt matter if we mess up an entry we shouldn't go back and fix it because it does not have to be perfect at all. Its just about interesting topics that some people carry journals and write in them every day like for a one hour or less.
Gia Says:
9/12/2009 4:40:52 PM
I was disappointed by how Grammar Girl talked about personal journaling as only a way to accidentally let secrets out and laugh at your younger self. The podcast seem to be saying that the only real reason to have a journal is to improve your writing technique. I know that better writing is the subject of the podcast, but improving yourself is an equally important goal of journaling. Journaling helps some people relieve stress and work out emotional issues. I once attended a lecture on journaling where the speaker said that keeping journals helped students do better on their finals, allowed prisoners to re-examine their lives and aided doctors in remembering more details about their patients. In my personal experience, it has encouraged me to do more with my life because I want something interesting to write about. "Dear Carys, today I watched YouTube videos all day for the fifth day in a row" does not make a good entry." Journaling has also made me pay attention to the world around me because I want to show my children and grandchildren what things are like now.
Grammar Girl Says:
9/12/2009 2:52:26 PM
@japanesetools at Twitter pointed out a program called MacJournal designed specifically for people who want to keep a journal on a Mac: http://www.marinersoftware.com/sitepage.php?page=85
Rachel Says:
9/11/2009 4:39:28 PM
"...a writing project that will get in front of readers." Though books have been written on the subject, this would make an interesting Q&D tip, or series of tips.
John Sanabria Says:
9/11/2009 12:30:00 PM
Interesting topic, in particular because I didn't have the 'journal' culture. In fact, one year ago, I started to take notes and write my memories about different professional issues. BTW, your voice is amazing and your podcast is like an oasis. Excellent work ;-)

Add Comment

 *
 *
 *
  Image to deter spam submissions
  To deter spam submissions, please type the letters from the image into the box below:
 *
 
  Fields marked with "*" are required